|
A plant used to stem the hunger pangs of African tribes
could soon be added to the meals of obese westerners
desperate to lose their excess pounds.
The Anglo-Dutch multinational Unilever is to develop
a new range of dieting aids, similar to its Slim-Fast
range, that will contain extracts of the hoodia plant,
a rare cactus found in southern Africa.
Last month it struck a $38m deal with the British botanical
firm, Phytopharm, for the commercial rights to use the
plant. The deal was greeted with enthusiasm by City
analysts and the Phytopharm share price shot up 11%
on the news, valuing the business at about $190m and
chief executive Dr Richard Dixey's personal stake at
about $36m.
For generations the San bushmen of southern Africa have
used hoodia in a different way to suppress hunger when
food is scarce or when hunting. "When children are feeling
hungry the San feed them hoodia so they don't feel hungry
all the time," said Axel Thoma, a trustee of the South
African San Council, which represents the tribes. "There
is a general problem in regional areas of food shortages.
The
food handouts are powdered milk and enriched [maize]
meal, and sometimes tins of fish, but that's it." The
problem in the developed world, where more than 20%
of the population is obese, is at the other end of the
scale.
The United States is the worst affected: obesity is
estimated to cost the economy $120bn a year. Drugs firms
are desperately seeking a chemical solution to the problem,
and therefore access to a multibillion-dollar market.
The
Phytopharm chief executive, a biochemist turned Buddhist
entrepreneur, has had his eye on the market for some
time. The firm looks to plants to provide treatments
for diseases as diverse as Alzheimer's in humans and
arthritis in dogs.
He
had been developing an appetite-suppressing drug based
on hoodia in a joint venture with Pfizer, the largest
drugs firm in the world. When it was given to overweight
men for two weeks in clinical trials, they ate fewer
calories and their body fat reduced. That deal fell
through last year, however, and so Dr Dixey turned to
Unilever, the owner of Ben & Jerry's ice-cream and Dove
soap as well as Slim-Fast, to see if the plant could
be added to food to help people lose weight.
Unilever
has considerable experience in the market, selling hundreds
of millions of dollars worth of Slim-Fast products last
year, but sales have slumped as slimmers have turned
to the Atkins diet.
Unilever said it would invest up to $40m to test the
plant extract for safety and develop a new range of
food and drink products over the next three years. Phytopharm
will receive an undisclosed portion of the money and
a fraction of the sales in royalties if the products
go on sale.
If the project gets this far the rewards could be enormous.
"Some people are talking about $600m a year in sales;
my suspicion is it will be more than $1bn or $2bn,"
said Erling Refsum, an analyst at Japanese bank Nomura.
"Up to 50% of the western population is overweight.
It's the biggest epidemic we are facing." The deal could
also benefit the finances of the San, although on a
much smaller scale. Phytopharm does not reveal how much
of its income from hoodia will be given to the South
African research agency CSIR, from which it licensed
the rights to the plant in 1997, but the San will only
get between 6% and 8% of it. Phytopharm paid money to
the CSIR some time ago due to its multimillion-dollar
deal with Pfizer, but the trust that will take the bushmen's
share is still being set up.
There
is 260,000 rand ($45,800) waiting in government coffers
that should be given to the tribes. This has been earmarked
for offices and infrastructure for the South African
San Council, Mr Thoma said.
The
bushmen should also receive a small portion of the deal
signed last month and a tiny fraction of product sales
in the future.
These
funds would be paid into the trust used for education
and buying back land that historically belonged to the
San. "It will pay for the younger generation to help
them get into higher education so we can rely on our
own people in future," said Mr Thoma. "If there is a
lot of money we will start buying land back that was
once taken from us, so we become landowners and secured."
There is an irony in the fact that the hoodia plant
is becoming rarer, particularly as tourists and unofficial
peddlers try to exploit it. Unilever will be setting
up vast farms to produce enough of it.
The
contrast between those with plenty and those without
is clear, but the billions to be made could provide
the thousands that could make an enormous difference
to the San tribes.
Fat
westerners may be last hope for broken bushmen Rory
Carroll in Johannesburg A drive through the windblown
San settlements of grass and wood scattered across southern
Africa is a depressing experience: families ravaged
by poverty, unemployment and alcoholism their hunter-gatherer
tradition a fading memory.
For
the past few years their leaders have spoken of a bonanza
from western pharmaceutical companies in payment for
the San Bushmen's knowledge of a plant that might one
day cure obesity. They have yet to see a penny. "They
are frustrated by the delay, but these are people who
take things as they are.
There
is not huge agitation yet," said Richard Wicksteed,
a documentary maker who has filmed them for two decades.
"The average San knows there is value in their medicinal
knowledge.
Having
used hoodia when they were starving, the irony of obese
westerners using it to lose weight is not lost on them."
Roger Chennels, a lawyer and spokesman for the San Council,
welcomed the chance to put the commercial development
of hoodia back on track in the wake of the aborted Pfizer
deal. "We've been expecting it.
We're
very pleased and excited about Unilever being the licensee.
It's the end of the period of waiting since the Pfizer
fall-out." If a portion of Unilever's millions does
reach the San it would buck a long, sad history of dispossession.
These
indigenous people of southern Africa have a culture
dating back 20,000 years. The more warrior-like Bantu
tribes from the north, then European colonialists and
finally the apartheid regime swept through their land,
pushing the San into dwindling pockets of territory.
The three San groups most closely associated with hoodia
the Khwe, Xu and Khomani number only a few thousand.
The total number of San across the Kalahari is estimated
at 100,000. Post-apartheid South Africa tried to redress
some of the injustice by granting them ownership of
more than 40,000 hectares. But their communities are
broken. Only a handful remain the hunter-gatherers of
western imagination.
The
rest scrabble what living they can in bleak settlements
which are often hundreds of kilometres from decent roads,
schools and clinics. "This is the last stand of the
San the last generation that still retains some of their
culture and heritage.
They
are a tiny people with a tiny voice," said Mr Wicksteed.
Some firms have already tried to pirate the San's knowledge
of the hoodia, and Unilever and Phytopharm are expected
to try to stop such practices. Chris De Plessis, a lawyer
representing the San in Botswana, said that few San
understood the ramifications of intellectual property
rights, and mistrust was growing that their leaders
might pocket the revenue if it ever comes.
|